Netflix’s limited series American Primeval, directed by Peter Berg, takes viewers on a raw and intense journey through the harsh realities of life in 1857 Utah Territory. With a six-part narrative, the show captures the struggles of survival and the violent clashes among settlers, Native tribes, Mormon militia, and U.S. forces.
A Glimpse Into the Storyline
Set during the Utah War, American Primeval follows Sara Rowell (Betty Gilpin), a mother traveling west with her son Devin (Preston Mota). They are in search of Devin’s father but face countless dangers, from harsh winters to violent confrontations. Their journey takes them to Fort Bridger, where they meet Isaac Reed (Taylor Kitsch), a reclusive frontiersman raised by the Shoshone tribe. Isaac becomes their reluctant guide through a treacherous landscape.
The series also intertwines fictional drama with historical events like the Mountain Meadows Massacre, where Mormon militia killed 150 settlers. This tragedy affects characters like Jacob (Dane DeHaan) and Abish Pratt (Saura Lightfoot-Leon), a newly married couple grappling with personal losses amidst widespread chaos.
Stunning Cinematography and Gritty Realism
From the first episode, American Primeval impresses with its breathtaking visuals. The rugged beauty of the untamed wilderness is captured with stark authenticity, highlighting the brutal conditions of frontier life. The series doesn’t shy away from portraying the grim realities—be it skinned animals, extreme weather, or unrelenting violence.
Complex Characters and Strong Performances
Betty Gilpin delivers a powerful performance as Sara, a mother torn between protecting her son and navigating a brutal world. Taylor Kitsch plays Isaac with rugged determination, though his character occasionally feels one-dimensional. Dane DeHaan and Saura Lightfoot-Leon bring depth to their roles as individuals caught in the crossfire of history.
The show also delves into the perspectives of Native tribes, particularly the Shoshone and Paiute, highlighting their struggles to resist colonization and protect their heritage.
Themes of Survival and Conflict
At its core, American Primeval explores humanity's struggle for land, freedom, and survival. The series paints a vivid picture of the violent beginnings of America, where every faction—settlers, Indigenous tribes, Mormon militia, and the U.S. Army—fights for dominance.
The constant threat of violence, especially for women like Sara and Abish, adds another layer of tension. The series also addresses the moral complexities of survival, showing how far individuals will go to protect their loved ones.
Strengths and Shortcomings
While the series is visually stunning and emotionally gripping, it doesn’t entirely break free from genre clichés. The story leans heavily on familiar tropes of Westerns, and some characters feel underdeveloped. Despite this, the well-choreographed action and raw storytelling make American Primeval a compelling watch.
Final Verdict
American Primeval is a gritty, unflinching portrayal of the American West. While it may not redefine the Western genre, it offers a gripping and harrowing look at the violent roots of modern America. The series is worth watching for its stunning visuals, strong performances, and its raw take on survival in an unforgiving world.
American Primeval is now streaming on Netflix.