Eurovision Semi-Finals: Why You Can't Vote for the Big Five (and Is That Really Fair?)
It's that time of year again—sequins are being sewn, key changes rehearsed, and wind machines tested to perfection. Eurovision season is upon us! If you've ever found yourself frantically reaching for your phone to vote for your favorite UK or Italian act during the semi-finals only to discover you can't, you're not alone. I've been there too, remote in hand, utterly confused. So what's going on with these so-called "Big Five" countries, and why do they get special treatment?
Who Are These Privileged Five Anyway?
France, Germany, Italy, Spain, and the United Kingdom—collectively known as the "Big Five"—skip the nail-biting semi-finals and cruise straight into Saturday night's Grand Final. And no, it's not because they have the best pyrotechnics or the most committed fans wearing national colors.
It all comes down to cold, hard cash. These five nations are Eurovision's biggest financial backers, with their broadcasters contributing significantly more to the European Broadcasting Union than other participants. They're essentially the wealthy sponsors picking up the tab for the glittery party we all enjoy. With Russia's departure in 2022, these powerhouses represent around 327 million people—more than all other 32 participating countries combined!
This VIP treatment began back in 2000 (originally as the "Big Four" until Italy made its comeback in 2011), but it's sparked ongoing debates among Eurovision devotees. Is paying your way to the final really in the spirit of the competition?
Advantage or Handicap? The Big Five Paradox
You might think bypassing the semi-finals would be like getting a free pass to the finale of your favorite talent show—a clear advantage, right? Well, it's surprisingly complicated.
On one hand, these countries can take creative risks without worrying about elimination. Remember Italy's Måneskin in 2021? That rock performance might have raised eyebrows in a semi-final dominated by pop acts, but it ultimately conquered the Grand Final. And let's be honest—without the Big Five's financial backing, some smaller countries might not be able to participate at all, robbing us of gems like Latvia's quirky performances or San Marino's surprising moments.
But there's a flip side. The Big Five miss out on valuable exposure during the semi-finals, when millions of viewers are forming their first impressions and favorites. By Saturday's Grand Final, viewers might feel less connected to entries they're seeing for the first time. It's like joining a party two hours late—everyone else has already formed their groups!
Recognizing this disadvantage, Eurovision introduced a change for 2024 (continuing into 2025) that allows Big Five acts to perform in the semi-finals as non-competitive showcases. So when you see the UK belting out their entry mid-semi-final but can't vote for them—that's why!
Does Money Talk? What History Tells Us
If automatic qualification truly offered an edge, you'd expect the Big Five to dominate the scoreboard every year, right? Let's check the receipts (as of May 2025):
- France: Despite sending some absolute bangers over the years, they haven't clinched a win since 2000 and have suffered several painful bottom-five finishes. Anyone remember the Twin Twin "Moustache" debacle?
- Germany: One solitary victory with Lena's "Satellite" in 2010, followed by what can only be described as a spectacular collection of last-place finishes. Remember poor Jendrik with his ukulele and middle finger costume?
- Italy: The overachievers of the group with Måneskin's rock triumph in 2021 and remarkably consistent placings—somehow avoiding the dreaded bottom five entirely.
- Spain: Zero wins despite sending some genuinely catchy entries. They've spent more time in the bottom five than they'd care to admit, though Chanel's "SloMo" in 2022 nearly broke their curse.
- United Kingdom: Oh dear. From the infamous "nul points" to a seemingly endless parade of bottom-five results. Sam Ryder's 2022 second place feels like a fever dream compared to their usual fortunes.
The numbers don't lie—buying your ticket to the final definitely doesn't guarantee success. In fact, outsiders like Sweden (with seven wins since 2000) and Ukraine (with three) have outperformed the Big Five consistently. Maybe there's something to be said for earning your place through the semi-finals after all?
Eurovision 2025: Will Money Finally Buy Happiness?
Looking at this year's betting odds, the Big Five's privileged status isn't translating into much optimism. Only France is given any realistic chance of cracking the top five, while bookmakers have already written off several of the other automatic qualifiers. Meanwhile, countries like Croatia and Switzerland—who fought through semi-finals—are among the frontrunners.
I've watched enough Eurovision to know that the semi-final experience often creates momentum. Viewers fall in love with performances, social media buzzes with new favorites, and by Saturday, these countries have already built their fanbases. The Big Five, despite their fancy financial status, have to win hearts in a single night.
The Verdict: Is It Fair?
After years of watching Eurovision from my living room (snacks and scorecards at the ready), I've come to see the Big Five situation as one of Eurovision's beautiful contradictions. Yes, they get to skip the qualifying round—but that might actually hurt their chances. They contribute more money—but often walk away with less glory. It's like being given a headstart in a race but having to wear slightly heavier shoes.
At the end of the day, Eurovision remains gloriously unpredictable. A great song with a memorable performance will triumph regardless of how it reached the final. Just ask Finland's Lordi or Portugal's Salvador Sobral—neither came from wealthy broadcasting nations, but both created unforgettable Eurovision moments.
So who are you cheering for this year? Do you think the Big Five deserve their automatic spots, or should everyone face the semi-final gauntlet? I'd love to hear your thoughts—especially if you're supporting an underdog from one of the pre-qualified nations! In the meantime, I'll be practicing my living room jury comments and preparing my Eurovision party playlist...
Â
