Jobaaj Stories
Julia Hartley-Brewer Slammed for Downplaying Narinder Kaur Upskirting Case
Broadcaster Julia Hartley-Brewer ignited a firestorm of criticism after comparing the upskirting of Narinder Kaur to a handbag theft. The controversy erupted following the news that actor Laurence Fox was charged with sharing an upskirting image of Kaur, leading Hartley-Brewer to draw a controversial parallel on social media.
The Incident and Backlash
Following an 11-month investigation, Fox was charged with a sexual offence for posting a compromising image of Kaur on social media in April 2024. Kaur, who waived her right to anonymity, previously described the incident as "unimaginably mortifying." Hartley-Brewer, however, responded to the news by tweeting about her own handbag theft, comparing the police response times. This sparked immediate outrage, with many accusing her of victim-shaming and trivializing a serious sexual offense. Users on X, formerly Twitter, criticized her attempt to equate a personal property crime with the violation of Kaur's privacy and dignity. Hartley-Brewer's defense, that she was comparing the policing of different crimes, did little to quell the backlash.
Understanding Upskirting and Cyberflashing
Upskirting, the act of taking a picture under someone's clothing without consent, is a serious crime. Fox's actions fall under Section 66A of the Sexual Offences Act 2003, which criminalizes the sharing of sexual images without consent, intending to cause alarm, distress, or humiliation. This reflects growing concerns around cyberflashing and online sexual harassment.
The Key Players
Narinder Kaur, a broadcaster known for appearances on Good Morning Britain and GB News, has become a prominent voice in this controversy. Laurence Fox, the actor facing charges, is known for his outspoken views and controversial past. Julia Hartley-Brewer's insensitive comparison brought further attention to the case, highlighting the complexities of public discourse surrounding sexual offenses.
Conclusion
Hartley-Brewer's comments underscore the ongoing need for greater sensitivity and understanding when discussing sexual assault and online harassment. The case highlights the gravity of upskirting and the importance of supporting victims. Fox's upcoming court appearance will be a significant development in this ongoing story.
