Discover the unexpected 2025 Peacock streaming cancellations, including fan-favorites like ‘Clean Slate’ & ‘The Recruit.’ Why were these shows cut short?


Newsletter

wave

😱 Peacock Streaming Cancellations Shock Fans in 2025 – What Happened? 🚫

In 2025, TV fans were left speechless as some of their favorite shows were unexpectedly cancelled, despite strong performances and loyal audiences. While iconic shows like The Simpsons are practically guaranteed to stick around, others, including some hit series from Peacock, were axed without warning. Here's a closer look at the surprising cancellations that left viewers puzzled and disappointed this year:

Clean Slate (2025) – A Historic Sitcom Cut Too Soon 💔

Clean Slate

One of the biggest surprises of 2025 was the cancellation of Clean Slate. Starring Laverne Cox, this groundbreaking sitcom followed Desiree Slate, a trans woman returning to her hometown to reunite with her estranged father. The show made history as the first sitcom to feature a transgender lead, earning rave reviews. Sadly, despite its praise, Clean Slate was cancelled just two months after its premiere, leaving fans devastated. 💔 The reasons behind its cancellation remain unclear, but it’s a huge loss for TV representation.

The Power (2023) – A Sci-Fi Drama's Sudden End ⚡

The Power

After a successful first season in 2023, The Power seemed like it was set for a bright future. The show, which follows teenage girls gaining the ability to electrify people, took a deep dive into feminist themes and sparked important conversations. But despite its promising start and strong cast (including Toni Collette and Auli'i Cravalho), the series was quietly cancelled. Speculation about behind-the-scenes drama, including the departure of director Reed Morano, could have played a part. ⚡

Based on a True Story (2023–2024) – A Dark Comedy Left Behind 🕵️‍♀️

Based on a True Story

Based on a True Story, starring Kaley Cuoco, started strong with its quirky blend of dark comedy and crime. It followed Ava and Nathan as they got involved with a serial killer, offering him a deal to talk about his crimes in exchange for money. But after a rocky second season, the show was cancelled, leaving viewers wondering what could have been. The second season wasn’t as strong as the first, and fans were hoping for a better conclusion. 🕵️‍♀️

Mythic Quest (2020–2025) – A Beloved Comedy’s Surprise Farewell 🎮

Mythic Quest

Fans were stunned when Mythic Quest, a comedy set in the world of video game development, was cancelled after its fourth season, especially since its spinoff Side Quest premiered just months earlier. The show, known for its quirky characters and hilarious workplace dynamics, was loved by fans. However, with the shift in creative direction and declining viewership, the decision to end the series came. 🎮 Fans are left with the bittersweet feeling of saying goodbye.

The Sex Lives of College Girls (2021–2025) – A College Comedy Cut Short 🍑

The Sex Lives of College Girls

The Sex Lives of College Girls, created by Mindy Kaling, had its fair share of success, following four college roommates navigating the ups and downs of adulthood and relationships. But in March 2025, after three seasons, it was announced that the show wouldn’t be returning for a fourth. Fans were left wondering if this was the last we’d see of Kimberly, Bela, Whitney, and Leighton. 🍑

The Recruit (2022–2025) – A Spy Drama’s Unexpected Exit 🕵️‍♂️

The Recruit

Despite a huge fan following and top ratings, The Recruit was cancelled after its second season. Starring Noah Centineo, the series follows a CIA lawyer caught up in a web of international espionage. The decision to cancel the show was unexpected, especially considering its popularity. 🕵️‍♂️ Netflix reportedly stated that the series didn’t align with their goals, leaving many fans scratching their heads.

Other Notable Cancellations from Peacock in 2025 🛑

  • Bookie (2023–2025): Despite a high Rotten Tomatoes score (90%), this Chuck Lorre comedy about a sports bookie was cancelled after two seasons. 😟

  • Mr. Throwback (2024): A mockumentary-style comedy with NBA star Stephen Curry was axed due to low viewership. 🏀

  • Hysteria! (2024): A comedy-horror series set during the 1980s Satanic Panic, cancelled after one season despite great reviews. 😱

  • Teacup (2024): A mysterious horror series about a worldwide threat was cancelled due to low ratings and a shift in tone. 🦠

FAQ

The cancellation of these shows was due to factors like low viewership, behind-the-scenes drama, and a shift in creative direction. Despite strong fanbases, they didn’t align with network goals.

Currently, The Sex Lives of College Girls is not planned to return for a fourth season, but there may be a possibility for the show to find a new home in the future. 🍑

The Power was cancelled despite a strong first season. Speculation points to creative differences and behind-the-scenes drama, such as the departure of its director, Reed Morano. ⚡

It’s unclear if Hysteria! or Teacup will return. While both shows were cancelled after their first seasons, fans are hoping for a revival on another platform. 😱

The cancellation of Mythic Quest came as a surprise. The decision was likely based on shifting audience interest and creative changes within the show.

Search Anything...!