Rabbitohs Shock Panthers in Controversial Match
The South Sydney Rabbitohs handed the Penrith Panthers a third straight defeat, winning 28-18 in a match marred by injury and controversy. The game highlighted the contrasting fortunes of the two teams: Souths celebrating a hard-fought victory despite injury concerns, and Penrith struggling with a woeful defensive display and a controversial bunker decision.
Johnston's Injury Casts Shadow Over Souths Victory
Souths' record try-scorer, Alex Johnston, made a triumphant return from an Achilles injury, only to suffer a left scapula injury in the first half. While the club remains hopeful the injury isn't serious, his absence could impact their upcoming clash against the Sydney Roosters. The injury adds to Souths' woes, with center Campbell Graham already sidelined. However, the return of superstar fullback Latrell Mitchell offers a significant boost. Johnston's contract situation adds another layer to the situation, with coach Wayne Bennett keen to retain the veteran winger.
Bunker Controversy Fuels Panthers Frustration
Penrith's performance was underwhelming, conceding 28 points in a disastrous first half described by coach Ivan Cleary as "comical." Their defensive woes continued, leaking 118 points across their first four games—a far cry from their usual defensive dominance. Adding insult to injury, a disallowed try for Moses Leota, deemed a questionable call by many, left fans and commentators outraged. Replays appeared to show Leota grounding the ball, fueling criticism of the bunker's decision. This costly error, along with a string of injuries to key players like Nathan Cleary and Dylan Edwards, further compounded their problems.
A Turning Point for Both Teams?
The Rabbitohs' victory, while tainted by Johnston's injury, showcases their resilience. For the Panthers, the three-game losing streak—their longest in five years—signals a significant downturn. Their defensive frailties and reliance on individual brilliance need addressing if they're to challenge for the premiership again. The upcoming matches against the Roosters (Souths) and the Cowboys (Panthers) are crucial for both teams, potentially setting the tone for the remainder of the season.