Jobaaj Stories
Cardinal Becciu: A Fall from Grace
The year is 2025. Less than an hour after cardinals met behind closed doors on April 29th, a press statement shocked the world. Cardinal Giovanni Angelo Becciu, once a powerful figure in the Vatican, announced he wouldn't participate in the upcoming conclave. His statement: "Having at heart the good of the church... I have decided to obey... the will of Pope Francis not to enter the conclave, while remaining convinced of my innocence." But to understand this, we need to go back five years.
It all started with a summons to the Casa Santa Marta, Pope Francis' residence. Cardinal Becciu, a man of quiet demeanor, received news that would shatter his career. Serious allegations regarding the management of the Holy See's finances had surfaced. The outcome? On September 24, 2020, the world learned that Pope Francis had accepted Becciu's resignation from his post as Prefect of the Congregation for the Causes of Saints, along with the rights associated with his cardinalate.
- A swift downfall: Becciu's resignation sent shockwaves through the Vatican and the Catholic world.
- Legal battles: He later sued *L’Espresso* for defamation, claiming the magazine's reporting led to his downfall.
Becciu's career, before the scandal, was a classic ascent within the Vatican hierarchy. Diplomat in Sudan, New Zealand, Cuba, and Angola, he rose to become the right-hand man to Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone. Pope Francis later elevated him to cardinal in 2018. However, a shadow loomed: a controversial real estate investment in London.
The investment, totaling €184 million in a property at 60 Sloane Avenue, was made through a Luxembourg-based hedge fund managed by a financier with a questionable reputation, Raffaele Mincione. This represented roughly a third of the Secretariat of State's cash assets! The Vatican financed this venture with a high-risk loan, secured against assets including funds from Peter's Pence—donations meant for the Church's administration and charitable works.
| Aspect | Details |
|---|---|
| Role | Former Prefect of the Congregation for the Causes of Saints; Substitute for General Affairs |
| Trial Outcome | Convicted of embezzlement and abuse of office; appeal pending |
| Conclave Participation | Withdrew, citing obedience to Pope Francis' wishes |
| Key Controversy | Controversial London property investment, questionable payments to associates |
The subsequent trial, dubbed "the trial of the century," concluded in December 2023 with Becciu's conviction on charges of embezzlement. He received a five-and-a-half-year prison sentence, a fine, and a lifetime ban from public office. He has appealed the verdict, which currently suspends the sanctions.
- Key allegations: The trial highlighted allegations of misappropriation of funds, including payments to Becciu's brother's cooperative and to Cecilia Marogna, a consultant accused of misusing funds intended for freeing a captive nun (an operation that never occurred).
- Pope Francis's stance: While initially expressing hope for Becciu's innocence, the Pope's later actions, such as inviting Becciu to a consistory, remain ambiguous regarding a full pardon.
Becciu's decision to withdraw from the conclave, while ostensibly out of respect for Pope Francis' wishes, raises canonical questions. The rules governing conclave participation are complex, and his status as a convicted but appealing cardinal created legal ambiguity. Ultimately, his withdrawal avoided potential controversy.
The Becciu case underscores the need for greater transparency and accountability in the Vatican's financial practices. His story serves as a cautionary tale, highlighting the complexities and challenges within the Catholic Church's governance.
Also Read: Cardinal Becciu Withdraws from Papal Conclave Amidst Scandal
